Research on the Weighting of Historical Building Value Assessment Indicators Considering the Influence of Subjective Scoring Differences

WANG Decai; SONG Wenhui; DING Na; MIU Junjie

doi:10.3724/j.gyjzG23072807

Volume 54 Issue 5

May 2024

Turn off MathJax

Article Contents

Abstract

References

Article Navigation > INDUSTRIAL CONSTRUCTION > 2024 > 54(5): 117-125

Zhao Ruofan, Qi Xingjun, Guo Dongmei, Yang Hongchao, Qi Sheng. Research on Nondestructive Testing and Evaluation of Stiffness of Stone Arch Bridges Based on Modal Testing[J]. INDUSTRIAL CONSTRUCTION, 2024, 54(10): 223-229. doi: 10.3724/j.gyjzG23051108

Citation:

WANG Decai, SONG Wenhui, DING Na, MIU Junjie. Research on the Weighting of Historical Building Value Assessment Indicators Considering the Influence of Subjective Scoring Differences[J]. INDUSTRIAL CONSTRUCTION, 2024, 54(5): 117-125. doi: 10.3724/j.gyjzG23072807

Citation:

PDF( 5011 KB)

Research on the Weighting of Historical Building Value Assessment Indicators Considering the Influence of Subjective Scoring Differences

doi: 10.3724/j.gyjzG23072807

College of Architecture and Art, Hefei University of Technology, Hefei 230601, China

Received Date: 2023-07-28
Available Online: 2024-06-22

Abstract

Abstract

The weighting of indicators in the evaluation of historical building value is typically based on the relative importance of each indicator, often overlooking the influence of subjective scoring discrepancies on these weights. However, such differences in subjective scoring reflect the reliability of scoring data and the degree of emphasis placed on high-value indicators. Considering them as factors influencing indicator weighting can lead to more objective and accurate evaluation results. This study introduced the information content weighting method and the mandatory distribution method, building upon traditional weighting methods. On one hand, the information content weighting method assigned weights based on the consistency of expert scores for the same indicator, thus compensating for the oversight of considering discrepancies in expert scores for the same indicator in weighting. On the other hand, the mandatory distribution method optimized the weighting intervals based on the differences in scores between existing indicators, enhancing the rationality of determining interval boundary parameters. After simulating and validating the feasibility and superiority of these two methods, the study further demonstrated their practical significance using the examples of the Xucun Mansion Ancestral Hall in Shexian County and the Wu Family Branch Ancestral Hall, aiming to provide more reliable and effective guidance for the conservation of historical buildings through value assessment.
- subjective rating,
- historical buildings,
- value assessment,
- index weighting,
- information weight method,
- forced distribution method

FullText(HTML)

References(21)

References

[1]	葛天阳,后文君,阳建强.基于GIS和AHP的历史地段建筑多级综合评价:以南京湖熟古镇核心地段为例[J].现代城市研究,2017(7):31-38.
[2]	唐倩倩. 基于十个试点城市认定评估实践的历史建筑价值构成与评估指标研究[D].苏州:苏州科技大学,2021.
[3]	DEL M S T T,TABRIZI S K. A methodological assessment of the importance of physical values in architectural conservation using Shannon entropy method[J].Journal of Cultural Heritage,2020,44:135-151.
[4]	宋刚,杨昌鸣.近现代建筑遗产价值评估体系再研究[J].建筑学报,2013(增刊2):198-201.
[5]	张星,李建沂. 基于GIS平台的建筑历史价值综合评价体系初探:以武汉汉口原租界历史街区为例[C]//2017中国城市规划年会论文集(09城市文化遗产保护).北京:2017:620-632.
[6]	徐进亮,舒帮荣,吴群.基于变权模型的历史建筑价值评价研究[J].四川建筑科学研究,2013,39(3):78-82.
[7]	MA H, LI S, CHAN C S. Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP)-based assessment of the value of non-World Heritage Tulou: a case study of Pinghe County, Fujian Province[J]. Tourism Management Perspectives, 2018, 26: 67-77.
[8]	余慧,刘晓.基于灰色聚类法的历史建筑综合价值评价[J].四川建筑科学研究,2009,35(5):240-242.
[9]	董文丽,祝立雄,李王鸣.基于模糊德尔菲法的历史文化名城保护规划实施评价研究[J].浙江大学学报(理学版),2017,44(6):749-756.
[10]	梁雪春,达庆利,朱光亚.我国城乡历史地段综合价值的模糊综合评判[J].东南大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2002(2):44-46.
[11]	赖明华,王晓鸣,罗爱道.基于正交设计的历史建筑综合价值评价研究[J].华中科技大学学报(城市科学版),2006(1):35-38.
[12]	张军,王室程.建筑遗产价值评估方法[J].哈尔滨工程大学学报,2017,38(10):1661-1668.
[13]	EBERHARDT S, POSPISIL M. EP heritage value assessment method proposed methodology for assessing heritage value of load-bearing structures[J]. International Journal of Architectural Heritage, 2022, 16(11): 1621-1641.
[14]	培庄.模糊集与随机集落影[M].北京:北京师范大学出版社,1985.
[15]	LÉVY P. Collective intelligence: mankind’s emerging world in cyberspace[M].Cambridge, MA: Perseus Books Group, 1997.
[16]	宋彦蓉,张宝元.基于地区现代化评价的客观赋权法比较[J].统计与决策,2015(11):82-86.
[17]	阮霁阳.地方政府数据开放平台服务质量评价研究:基于群AHP-熵权法组合权重的TOPSIS实证分析[J].云南行政学院学报,2021,23(6):43-52.
[18]	李刚,李建平,孙晓蕾,等.主客观权重的组合方式及其合理性研究[J].管理评论,2017,29(12):17-26 ,61.
[19]	谢红梅,谢如欢.强制分布法的优化设计[J].企业管理,2015(2):86-88.
[20]	余嘉欣.沉睡资源变资产古村落蝶变换新颜[N].金融时报,2023-10-10(001).
[21]	马毅.数字化背景下非物质文化遗产的保护与利用[J].大众文艺,2019(24):3-4.

Relative Articles

[1]	YANG Chunxia, CHEN Tao, ZHANG Yongtao, WAN Peng, WU Jun. Automatic Identification of Modal Parameters of Wind Turbine Towers Under Harmonic Excitation[J]. INDUSTRIAL CONSTRUCTION, 2024, 54(4): 134-141. doi: 10.3724/j.gyjzG23080713
[2]	GONG Fuyuan, HUANG Zhe, PAN Zuanfeng, ZHAO Yuxi, ZENG Bin. Multi-Physics and Multi-Scale Analysis of Prestress Loss and Deflection in Large-Scale Structures Under the Influence of Environmental Humidity[J]. INDUSTRIAL CONSTRUCTION, 2024, 54(10): 21-30. doi: 10.3724/j.gyjzG24090902
[3]	HUO Linsheng, LI Hongnan, YANG Zhuodong, ZHOU Jing. Research Advances of Intelligent Detection and Monitoring Techniques for Loosening of Steel Structure Bolted Connections[J]. INDUSTRIAL CONSTRUCTION, 2023, 53(9): 10-17. doi: 10.13204/j.gyjzG23080112
[4]	WANG Ling, YANG Jianping, GUO Xiaohua. Experiments of Determining Steel Grades by Nondestructive Inspection of Leeb Hardness[J]. INDUSTRIAL CONSTRUCTION, 2022, 52(12): 195-199,194. doi: 10.13204/j.gyjzG21101901
[5]	LI Hongyi, SHAO Weiwei, ZHU Zhanlong, YANG Weijun. Quantitative Damage Identification of Frame Structure Based on Wavelet Packet Energy Curvature Difference Under Environmental Excitation[J]. INDUSTRIAL CONSTRUCTION, 2022, 52(10): 78-83. doi: 10.13204/j.gyjzG21112501
[6]	LIU Yang, SHAO Zhiwei, ZHANG Huijie, ZHAO Weitao, ZHANG Lei, CHA Xiaoxiong. RESEARCH ON NONDESTRUCTIVE TESTING OF CFST BY ULTRASONIC TOMOGRAPHY[J]. INDUSTRIAL CONSTRUCTION, 2021, 51(10): 189-200. doi: 10.13204/j.gyjzG21020313
[7]	QU Ming, SHAO Zhiwei, ZHAO Weitao, CHA Xiaoxiong. RESEARCH ON NONDESTRUCTIVE TESTING OF GROUTING SLEEVE MEMBERS BY ULTRASONIC TOMOGRAPHY[J]. INDUSTRIAL CONSTRUCTION, 2021, 51(9): 207-215. doi: 10.13204/j.gyjzG21020316
[8]	HU Weibing, YANG Jia, WANG Long, HOU Yanfang. STUDY ON DAMAGE DETECTION AND QUANTIFICATION OF ANCIENT BUILDING TIMBER STRUCTURES BASED ON LAMINATION THEORY AND BP NEURAL NETWORKS[J]. INDUSTRIAL CONSTRUCTION, 2020, 50(11): 71-77,111. doi: 10.13204/j.gyjzG20020501
[10]	Hu Juan, Song Yifan, Sun Xiaoyi. DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION CONTROL OF THE SPECIAL-SHAPED CAP SUPPORT FOR THE CAST-IN-PLACE LONG SPAN SELF-ANCHORED ARCH BRIDGE[J]. INDUSTRIAL CONSTRUCTION, 2014, 44(06): 85-89. doi: 10.13204/j.gyjz201406020
[11]	Mao Lisheng, Wu Jiaye, Huang Botai. STUDY ON THE IMPACT OF CONCRETE CRACK SURFACE PRESSURE ON THE DEPTH TEST RESULTS[J]. INDUSTRIAL CONSTRUCTION, 2013, 43(6): 146-149. doi: 10.13204/j.gyjz201306030
[12]	Guo Liqun, Li Anlu, Peng Xingqian. THE RESEARCH ON RAMMED-EARTH MATERIAL COMPRESSIVE STRENGTH NONDESTRUCTIVE TESTING FOR FUJIAN TULOU(EARTH-BUILDING)[J]. INDUSTRIAL CONSTRUCTION, 2013, 43(12): 167-172. doi: 10.13204/j.gyjz201312031
[13]	Gan Lin, Li Hailong. COMPARATIVE STUDY ON MODAL PARAMETER IDENTIFICATION TIME DOMAIN METHODS FOR FRAME STRUCTURE[J]. INDUSTRIAL CONSTRUCTION, 2013, 43(8): 29-33,23. doi: 10.13204/j.gyjz201308006
[14]	LüJiangen, Wang Ronghui. DETERIORATION EXAMINATION AND REINFORCEMENT OF CFST TIED ARCH BRIDGE[J]. INDUSTRIAL CONSTRUCTION, 2012, 42(8): 158-161. doi: 10.13204/j.gyjz201208031
[15]	Liu Xiang, Gao Zhenning, Li Hai. MODAL ANALYSIS OF MW GRADE WIND GENERATOR TOWER[J]. INDUSTRIAL CONSTRUCTION, 2012, 42(2): 62-65. doi: 10.13204/j.gyjz201202014
[16]	Sui Lili, Quan Xinrui, Xing Feng, Zhang Hongyuan. STATE-OF-THE-ART OF RESEARCH ON DURABILITY OF POST-TENSIONED CONCRETE BRIDGES[J]. INDUSTRIAL CONSTRUCTION, 2011, 41(1): 105-111. doi: 10.13204/j.gyjz201101025
[17]	Xu Shidai, Wang Fengquan. MODE PARAMETER IDENTIFICATION OF ENGINEERING STRUCTURE BASED ON ARMA MODEL[J]. INDUSTRIAL CONSTRUCTION, 2007, 37(5): 20-22. doi: 10.13204/j.gyjz200705005
[18]	Wang Gang, Yao Qianfeng. STUDY ON MODAL IDENTIFICATION OF FRAME STRUCTURE UNDER AMBIENT EXCITATION[J]. INDUSTRIAL CONSTRUCTION, 2004, 34(12): 45-47. doi: 10.13204/j.gyjz200412012