Research on Protective Reuse of Industrial Heritage Based on Multi-Attribute Decision Making Method: Taking Six Heritage Sites in Qingdao as an Example
-
摘要: 实现工业遗产的保护性再利用与城市可持续发展的共融互动一直是政府与企业等决策者关注与迫切解决的问题。从多属性辅助决策的角度,运用“偏好排序组织评估法(PROMETHEE)”理论可以有效辅助决策工业遗产的再利用问题。基于PROMETHEE多标准多属性分析理论,以青岛市的六处工业遗产为例,运用定性与定量等多种综合性分析方法,在工业遗产再利用对策层面提出了一套切实可行的优、劣势排序选择方法,可为各遗产点找到最为合适的再利用对策与模式提供理论依据,为解决工业遗产高质量再利用问题提供一种合适的实践方法。研究发现,以往很难通过经验性分析判断再利用方式的遗产,经由PROMETHEE多准则决策方法的数据分析可以帮助进行决策判断。在研究所选择的六处案例中,基于PROMETHEE理论,分别为六处遗产找到了最为适合的再利用对策与方式。
-
关键词:
- 工业遗产 /
- PROMETHEE理论 /
- 决策辅助
Abstract: The integration and interaction between the protective reuse of industrial heritage and sustainable urban development has always been a concern and urgent solution for decision-makers such as the government and enterprises. From the perspective of multi-attribute decision-making, the application of the "PROMETHEE" theory can effectively assist in decision-making on the reuse of industrial heritage. Based on the PROMETHEE multicriteria and multi-attribute analysis theory, taking six industrial heritage sites in Qingdao as an example, a practical and feasible method for ranking and selecting strengths and weaknesses in industrial heritage reuse strategies was proposed by using various comprehensive analysis methods such as qualitative and quantitative analysis. This can provide theoretical basis for finding the most suitable reuse strategies and models for heritage sites, and provide a suitable practical method for solving the problem of high-quality reuse of industrial heritage. Research has found that it used to be difficult to determine the inheritance of reuse methods through empirical analysis, and data analysis using the PROMETHEE multi-criteria decision-making method can help make decision judgments. Among the six selected cases in the research institute, based on the PROMETHEE theory, the most suitable reuse strategies and methods were found for each of the six heritage sites.-
Key words:
- industrial heritage /
- PROMETHEE theory /
- decision-making support
-
[1] 徐苏斌,青木信夫,张松,等.笔谈:变"锈"为"秀",工业遗产保护和再利用新思路新发展[J].中国文化遗产, 2022(3):4-18. [2] 朱怡晨,李昂.工业遗产推动城市可持续更新的杰出案例:马萨诸塞州当代艺术博物馆MASS MoCA[J].中国园林, 2022, 38(7):91-96. [3] 刘伯英.工业遗产:为历史文化名城增添新亮点[J].世界建筑, 2022(12):83-86. [4] 赵子杰,徐苏斌,田甜,等.建筑师价值认知下的工业遗产城市设计研究[J].南方建筑, 2021(4):24-30. [5] 余文婷,刘家明.韩国抱川艺术谷工业遗产更新的探索[J].工业建筑, 2019, 49(5):36-40. [6] 佟玉权.工业景观遗产及其结构性保护的路径探索[J].城市发展研究, 2015, 22(8):107-111. [7] BOTTERO M, D'ALPAOS C, OPPIO A. Ranking of adaptive reuse strategies for abandoned industrial heritage in vulnerable contexts:A multiple criteria decision aiding approach[J]. Sustainability, 2019, 11(3):785-803. [8] 刘丽东,马仁锋,吴丹丹,等.资源型城市工业遗产创意活化及其空间组织研究[J].上海国土资源, 2021, 42(4):14-27. [9] 肖明,李相民.歼侦机执行侦察任务前挂载方案预先选取[J].舰船电子工程, 2015, 35(6):100-104. [10] BRANS J P, VINCKE P H, MARESCHAL B. How to select and how rank project:the PROMETHEE method[J]. European Journal of Operational Research, 1986, 24(2):228-238. [11] 张慧洁.多属性决策在武汉南岸嘴及龟北片工业遗产价值评价中的应用研究[D].武汉:华中农业大学, 2014:16-23. [12] 任剑,高阳,王坚强,等.随机多准则决策的PROMETHEEⅡ方法[J].管理学报, 2009, 6(10):1319-1322. [13] FIGUEIRA J, GRECO S, EHRGOTT M. Multiple criteria decision analysis:state of the art surveys[M]. Boston, MA, USA:Springer Science Business Media, 2005:163-196. [14] 王润生,王大为,刘敏,等.青岛大港工业遗产本体价值评价[J].工业建筑, 2023, 53(2):79-86.
点击查看大图
计量
- 文章访问数: 74
- HTML全文浏览量: 11
- PDF下载量: 3
- 被引次数: 0